Untitled Document
It has been said that anti-Catholicism is the last acceptable prejudice. How
true this is, and it is subtle. Even when it is not so subtle, we hesitate to
complain.
In the case of the upcoming movie “The Golden Compass,” the anti-Catholicism
that the books are based on is there for all to see. And we shouldn’t hesitate
to complain — boycott the movie and don’t buy the books.
My son likes books of this genre — having read J.R.R. Tolkein and C.S. Lewis,
not to mention the Harry Potter series — and he checked out of the library the
books by Philip Pullman on which the movie is based. This was a few years ago,
when as part of the bedtime family routine I’d read to him, although he’d been
reading for many years.
As we read through the first book of the trilogy, “The Golden Compass,” I gradually
became uneasy with the imagery and with the terms used. For example, the evil
ones are “the magisterium” and priests are all evil. Children are being snatched
up by the General Oblation Board — so they would become “oblates” to this evil
magisterium.
It also includes a scenario whereby the authorities are trying to sever the
souls of the children from them, making them zombies. That was actually pretty
creepy.
We made it through the first book and began the second, but my increasing unease
with the language made me stop. I told him we just could not continue reading
the books.
Years later, we received the booklet from the Catholic League for Religious
and Civil Rights called “The Golden Compass: Agenda Unmasked” and he read it
and declared he would never finish the series. This booklet is available online
from the Catholic League at www.catholicleague.org, or by calling 212-371-3191.
With 95 footnotes in a 24-page booklet, it is well-researched and right to the
point about Pullman’s agenda to inculcate atheism into children.
You simply cannot hide the anti-Catholic nature of the books, with terms like
inquisition, magisterium, and mention of a Vatican council. He tries to make
it look like it is an amalgam of Catholicism and Protestantism, with a Pope
John Calvin, but that is probably because he wants to implicate all of Christianity.
I’ll include one quote from the hero, Lord Asirel, speaking of his plans: “This
will mean then the end of the church, Marisa, the end of the magisterium, the
end of all those centuries of darkness!”
Could he be more clear?
While we were fussing over Harry Potter — books in which at least the hero
triumphs through loyalty, bravery and kindness — the “His Dark Materials” trilogy
has been winning awards and outselling Harry Potter in England, and migrating
to the movies.
When we don’t understand our faith, fully embracing the teachings of the Church
and living our faith to its fullest, we are vulnerable to works like “The Golden
Compass,” “The Subtle Knife” and “The Amber Spyglass,” which make up the “His
Dark Materials” trilogy.
Nicole Kidman, a Catholic and a star in the movie, has said she doesn’t believe
the movie is anti-Catholic; but one can reasonably ask if she knows her faith
enough to even spot anti-Catholicism? One has to know the meaning of the term
magisterium before being offended by its misuse.
So, let’s arm ourselves with knowledge and use our economic power. And take
this as a warning: It is easy to be deceived.
Paula Glover is editor of The Monitor, newspaper of the Diocese of
Trenton, N.J.