Here’s the
second story: Over the past eight months, I’ve met and talked
with hundreds of Catholics who are very rightly upset about the
abuse scandal in the Church. A lot of our people are angry --
especially parents -- that a priest they trust might be capable
of a terrible sexual crime against children. But what really
incenses Catholics, what really enrages them, is the feeling
that bishops who knew better did nothing to protect the faithful
they were entrusted to lead. A lot of Catholics are far angrier
at the American bishops than they are at the priests who actually
committed the crimes.
Now I know
a lot of successful business leaders, and most of them are good,
decent men and women. I also know a lot of bishops, and none
of them is indifferent or callous to the people he leads -- in
fact, all of the ones I know are men I also admire for their dedication.
But in the
wake of Enron, Arthur Anderson, WorldCom, Adelphia, Tyco and a
national sex abuse scandal, I think it’s fair to say that we’ve
got two big problems. The first is a problem of leadership in
all our public institutions, not just business and religion.
The second is a much deeper problem in American culture at large,
a crisis in personal moral character at the grassroots level.
Let’s talk
about leadership first. What makes a good leader? Two things:
character and competence. You need the professional skills necessary
to the task; that’s competence. And you need the moral conscience
to use those skills properly; that’s character.
A good leader
creates a vision that other people can believe in and build together.
And a good leader always acts honestly. Year after year, in almost
every professional study, people rank honesty as the single most
important quality in a leader. In 32 years, first as a priest
and now as a bishop, I’ve seen again and again that people will
accept almost any hardship or bad news if they know you’re being
straight with them.
Even
more importantly, a good leader will put the needs of his people
before his own. Being a pastor is very much like being a parent.
If a father really loves his children, they’ll know it, and they’ll
forgive him almost anything. And if a father doesn’t love his
children, they’ll know that too, and they’ll forgive him nothing.
People followed Jesus of Nazareth because He lived for them, He
died for them and He created hope for them. That's what a real
leader looks like. And I think we don’t see enough of that anywhere
today in American public life.
Talented
people who work honestly and creatively deserve to enjoy the fruits
of their labor. Making a lot of money is not a moral problem
for Catholics. But how much is too much, in the face of
other people’s poverty? And what do we do with the
money we earn, in the face of other people’s needs? The flaw
in American leadership in 2002 is that, too often, it’s disconnected
from the people it serves, focused on short-term gain, and blind
to the links between public behavior and personal moral integrity.
And it’s a flaw that’s been growing for decades. Nixon and Watergate
and Clinton and Lewinsky are different symptoms of the same illness.
The philosopher
Hugo Grotius once said that, "A man cannot govern a nation
if he cannot govern a city; he cannot govern a city if he cannot
govern a family; he cannot govern a family unless he can govern
himself; and he cannot govern himself unless his passions are
subject to reason." And I’d add that a man’s reason can’t
truly serve himself or anyone else until he roots it in a moral
conscience.
As
a citizen, I think one of the worst moments in recent political
history was when John F, Kennedy promised a Texas audience that
he’d keep his Catholic faith out of his public service. I think
all Americans – not just Catholics – have been paying for that
mistake for 40 years. It’s one of the turning points in our community
life where this unhealthy fracture between public behavior and
personal belief began to grow.
I want
my elected officials to inform their actions with their religious
and moral beliefs, even if I don’t agree with them. I want them
to do it prudently and in a spirit of reasonable compromise --
but on the hard issues, I want them to act on their principles,
because then I can respect them. I can’t respect and I can’t
trust an elected official, or any other leader, who claims that
he or she personally believes one thing, but then publicly does
another -- whether the issue involves abortion or the death penalty
or prescription medicines for the elderly or affordable housing
for the poor.
One of the
most interesting stories I’ve seen in the past decade was a little
news item in the Denver Post back in December 1993. I was a bishop
in South Dakota then, but I often read the Denver papers, and
I’ve never forgotten this story. If you go to the parade ground
at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs, you’ll see carved
into a wall, in large letters, the academy honor code: We will
not lie, cheat or steal, nor tolerate among us anyone who does.
The Post reported in 1993 that because of the inadequate ethical
formation of incoming cadets, the academy had established a sort
of Morality 101 program to bring the cadets up to speed. These
incoming cadets were the cream of American high schools, the cream
of a generation that will run the country in 20 years – and many
of them needed a remedial class in basic ethics.
Now that’s
a potential problem for every aspect of our national leadership,
but it also points to the deeper problem in American life that
I mentioned at the beginning. Americans now live in a country
where marketing and entertainment run our popular culture. Every
hour of every day we’re sold the ideas that no matter how much
we have, we need more right now; that freedom is the absence of
commitments; that nothing lasts -- especially relationships with
other people; that “choice” is good even if the choices don’t
mean anything; and that authority is hypocritical.
I’m overstating
things, but not by much. Just spend a couple of nights watching
MTV or even the “adult” shows on network television. Or watch
the car commercials for Mitsubishi or Nissan – they’re really
a kind of product worship.
When Adam
Smith praised the rise of commerce two centuries ago, he did it
in the context of a moral order that limited and guided the market.
That moral order is much, much weaker today, and that’s why Christopher
Lasch and others have talked so critically about the market invading
every aspect of our lives. We’re very close to becoming what
Lasch called a “culture of narcissism.” We’re living in an environment
where the traditional American ideal of community -- a group
of people united in mutual concern around shared principles and
hopes -- is being replaced by a collection of individual appetites
that are kept more or less constantly dissatisfied. Our marketing
is too effective for our own good. It’s teaching our young people
to be permanently ungrateful and permanently self-centered. We
have a lot of material things, but Americans are not a happy people.
John
Adams once wrote, “Statesmen may plan and speculate for liberty,
but it is religion and morality alone which can establish the
principles upon which freedom can securely stand. The only foundation
of a free constitution is pure virtue.”
I want to
quote Adams as I conclude my remarks because it’s not enough to
know we have a problem. The point is, what can we do about
it? Well, if you do nothing else after our discussion today,
go read David McCullough’s terrific biography of John Adams.
Adams was a founder of our country, and therefore we owe him for
much of the freedom we enjoy today. But he also found a way to
perfectly combine public service, moral character and religious
faith. Adams always argued against slavery, and he did so because
he felt that it violated human dignity, ignored the Gospel and
was unworthy of a religious people. But I think the most revealing
fact about Adams was his relationship with his wife Abigail.
Adams loved his wife and his children with a tenderness and fidelity
that spanned a lifetime. St. Augustine once said, “to be faithful
in little things is a big thing.” Adams never allowed the big
demands of his public life to eclipse the seemingly “little” things
that were really the important things – a devotion to his
wife, his children, his friends and his God.
Devotion
to family sounds like a simple thing, and it is. Gratitude, humility,
faithfulness – these all are simple things. They’re also very
difficult. It’s easy to talk about fixing the problems of American
society with big national programs and policies, because we can
always blame somebody else when they don’t work.
Personal
change, personal moral integrity, personal fidelity to people
and principles – that’s much harder work, because we’re stuck
with the clay of who we are, and there’s nobody to blame but ourselves
if we fail. But in persisting in these little things, we accomplish
a big thing. We affect others. A reporter once asked
Mother Teresa the secret of her success. She answered that she
wasn’t called to succeed, but only to try. Success was God’s
business. Trying was her business. She wasn’t called to find
big solutions to poverty, but to live the little solution of personal
love that would become a good infection in the hearts of other
people.
We each have
that same vocation, especially all of you here today, because
each of you in his or her own way is a leader. Our lives matter.
We’re here for a reason. One life, lived well, can begin to change
the world.
So lead well,
with honesty and vision and moral character and unselfishness.
Lead well, not only with what you say, but with what you do –
and in your example, that’s where the renewal of American public
life will begin.